The other day I'm working in Truancy Court in a fairly small courtroom and they add on some guy who was arrested the night before. Not important why, but if the cops shoot at you and miss it should be taken as a signal that it's time to reexamine how you live your life. He needs a bail hearing now, and I'm available to do it.
His girlfriend shows up too, and he's telling her "I love you... Call my family and tell them where I am.... Wait for me and I'll be out soon...I love you..." The jailers tell him to stop talking to people in the audience, and tell the g/f to knock it off or they'll kick her out. So he turns to me:
"You're my lawyer? I can talk to you, right?"
"Right. Let's talk about where you're going to live if you get released."
He looks right at me.
"I LOVE YOU. CALL MY FAMILY AND TELL THEM WHERE I AM. I LOVE YOU!"
Weirdo. Just when you think you've seen it all.
Sunday, November 16, 2008
Thursday, November 6, 2008
A feel-good story
I used to do a lot of dependency work, representing parents whose kids had been taken away by the Department of Social & Health Services. About a year ago the State centralized most of that work and I moved on to other things. I can't say I miss it much. The stories were usually tragic, the clients usually had personality disorders or some other mental disability, and the social workers were inconsistent. Some were terrific (Hi Mom!) some were just serving time, and some were on power trips.
Anyway, the other day I was in the courthouse doing some other work and some guy came up to me in the hallway and said
"You're Erskine, right?"
"Yeeesss..." ( I feel that "Who's askin?" is unprofessional)
"I'm a social worker with OPD [the agency that now represents parents in dependencies]. I've been working on Tom Joad's case."
Now, Tom was an unusual case for a dependency. He was a single parent who honestly loved his son and worked hard at being a good parent to him. He didn't abuse substances and kept an immaculate house. The difficulty was that his son had some challenging mental health/developmental issues and Tom wasn't all that bright himself. He also had a rigid approach to life that didn't mesh well with the school counseling or DSHS staff, and frankly probably not too well with his son's needs. I thought taking the kid out of home was overkill; the State didn't and we had a major battle in court over it. Lots of parents in that position can't be bothered to show up consistently for visits with their kids; Tom showed up early every time and was constantly demanding permission to take his son fishing or camping.
Back to the courthouse:
"I read all the transcripts and exhibits on that case. You really fought hard for that guy. He's about to get his son back, and you laid the foundation for that to happen. I always wanted to meet you and thank you for what you did."
You never get rich doing what I do. The big money lawyers are in the downtown skyscrapers. I tried that right out of law school and found that arguing about moving money from one pocket to another bored me to tears. I make enough money to keep my family comfortable, and that's all I need.
The real rewards are the memories:
The hugs from a defendant and/or his family as the guards take the shackles off after the jury says "Not Guilty" or the judge says "Motion to Suppress granted".
(Here's the difference between prosecutors and defense lawyers:
Prosecutor: "How can you let those people hug you?"
Defender: "How can I not?")
The teenager who says "Now that I finished inpatient and have been clean for a year, I understand why you never let up on me about not using meth. Want to come to my high school graduation?"
Got another one this week.
Anyway, the other day I was in the courthouse doing some other work and some guy came up to me in the hallway and said
"You're Erskine, right?"
"Yeeesss..." ( I feel that "Who's askin?" is unprofessional)
"I'm a social worker with OPD [the agency that now represents parents in dependencies]. I've been working on Tom Joad's case."
Now, Tom was an unusual case for a dependency. He was a single parent who honestly loved his son and worked hard at being a good parent to him. He didn't abuse substances and kept an immaculate house. The difficulty was that his son had some challenging mental health/developmental issues and Tom wasn't all that bright himself. He also had a rigid approach to life that didn't mesh well with the school counseling or DSHS staff, and frankly probably not too well with his son's needs. I thought taking the kid out of home was overkill; the State didn't and we had a major battle in court over it. Lots of parents in that position can't be bothered to show up consistently for visits with their kids; Tom showed up early every time and was constantly demanding permission to take his son fishing or camping.
Back to the courthouse:
"I read all the transcripts and exhibits on that case. You really fought hard for that guy. He's about to get his son back, and you laid the foundation for that to happen. I always wanted to meet you and thank you for what you did."
You never get rich doing what I do. The big money lawyers are in the downtown skyscrapers. I tried that right out of law school and found that arguing about moving money from one pocket to another bored me to tears. I make enough money to keep my family comfortable, and that's all I need.
The real rewards are the memories:
The hugs from a defendant and/or his family as the guards take the shackles off after the jury says "Not Guilty" or the judge says "Motion to Suppress granted".
(Here's the difference between prosecutors and defense lawyers:
Prosecutor: "How can you let those people hug you?"
Defender: "How can I not?")
The teenager who says "Now that I finished inpatient and have been clean for a year, I understand why you never let up on me about not using meth. Want to come to my high school graduation?"
Got another one this week.
Monday, October 13, 2008
What's my winning percentage?
Prosecutors like to talk about winning over 90% of their trials. What that ignores is that they pick the cases they take to trial. I, like every defense lawyer, regularly get sweetheart offers on marginal cases. That leaves the cases where there's either a huge difference of opinion or, more often, no real defense and a client who won't face reality.
Last year I had a kid who broke into the local burger stand and swiped some change and a case of Frappucinos (maybe we should have made him drink them as punishment, but anyway....) He goes to the cop shop a block away, walks up to the first uniform he sees, and says:
"I'm turning myself in."
"For what?"
"I just robbed Joe's Burgers."
"Wait right there...[radio] Hey Barney! Drive by Joe's Burgers and see if somebody broke into it!"
"[radio] Yeah, the window's busted and some jerk pried the till! There's most of a case of Frappucinos across the alley here too!"
"You have the right to remain silent....."
"Never mind all that, I DID IT!"
When this works its way through the system, the prosecutor really doesn't want to spend time on the trial. Young Einstein, on the other hand, wants his day in court. No matter what the prosecutor offers to drop, he's going to trial!
I, of course, am scratching my head for something to say in his defense. "My mom's on crank and last I heard my dad was in prison again" may be true but is an argument for sentencing, not guilt.
Naturally, this got added to the prosecutor's winning percentage. Kid ended up convicted of a lot more than he would have if he'd made a deal.
Contrast this with the Great Crow Caper. My client in that one had a pet crow that lived in a cage on his porch. The door stayed open except at night (to protect him from raccoons) and the crow would come out, fly around, chase thrown bottle caps, sit on my client's shoulder, and eventually hop back into his cage to rest.
Problem is that what my client saw as a happy friendship was seen by the State as "keeping captive wildlife without a permit". The game wardens eventually got a warrant to seize the bird. Acting on the warrant, they search the client's whole house (for the record, it is a foul libel that game wardens are hired from the guys who flunked the State Patrol IQ exam), finding funny white powders in the back bedroom along with a variety of other illicit materials. This leads to the client being charged with a bunch of drug crimes good for about five years in the concrete hotel.
I file a suppression motion, basically arguing that there was no need to toss the entire house to confiscate a bird off the porch. Two days before the hearing, the prosecutor calls and offers to reduce everything to a misdemeanor possession of marijuana and two days in jail. After some arm twisting, my client accepts.
Technically, the prosecutor got to put that one in the "win" column. After all, my client was convicted of a crime. On the other hand, a weekend in jail is a big improvement over five years in prison. Personally, I felt good about the result.
Last year I had a kid who broke into the local burger stand and swiped some change and a case of Frappucinos (maybe we should have made him drink them as punishment, but anyway....) He goes to the cop shop a block away, walks up to the first uniform he sees, and says:
"I'm turning myself in."
"For what?"
"I just robbed Joe's Burgers."
"Wait right there...[radio] Hey Barney! Drive by Joe's Burgers and see if somebody broke into it!"
"[radio] Yeah, the window's busted and some jerk pried the till! There's most of a case of Frappucinos across the alley here too!"
"You have the right to remain silent....."
"Never mind all that, I DID IT!"
When this works its way through the system, the prosecutor really doesn't want to spend time on the trial. Young Einstein, on the other hand, wants his day in court. No matter what the prosecutor offers to drop, he's going to trial!
I, of course, am scratching my head for something to say in his defense. "My mom's on crank and last I heard my dad was in prison again" may be true but is an argument for sentencing, not guilt.
Naturally, this got added to the prosecutor's winning percentage. Kid ended up convicted of a lot more than he would have if he'd made a deal.
Contrast this with the Great Crow Caper. My client in that one had a pet crow that lived in a cage on his porch. The door stayed open except at night (to protect him from raccoons) and the crow would come out, fly around, chase thrown bottle caps, sit on my client's shoulder, and eventually hop back into his cage to rest.
Problem is that what my client saw as a happy friendship was seen by the State as "keeping captive wildlife without a permit". The game wardens eventually got a warrant to seize the bird. Acting on the warrant, they search the client's whole house (for the record, it is a foul libel that game wardens are hired from the guys who flunked the State Patrol IQ exam), finding funny white powders in the back bedroom along with a variety of other illicit materials. This leads to the client being charged with a bunch of drug crimes good for about five years in the concrete hotel.
I file a suppression motion, basically arguing that there was no need to toss the entire house to confiscate a bird off the porch. Two days before the hearing, the prosecutor calls and offers to reduce everything to a misdemeanor possession of marijuana and two days in jail. After some arm twisting, my client accepts.
Technically, the prosecutor got to put that one in the "win" column. After all, my client was convicted of a crime. On the other hand, a weekend in jail is a big improvement over five years in prison. Personally, I felt good about the result.
Saturday, October 4, 2008
Put your kid first dammit!
One of the toughest situations for a juvenile defender to deal with is one where the client is the subject of a custody fight between the parents. Each parent wants to blame the other for the fact that the kid is in trouble, each wants to bring all the allegations from the custody battle up in Juvenile Court, and each wants to be in control of what happens with the kid.
It's a given that the kid has to make his/her own decisions about the case. In Juvenile Court, though, they tend to rely on their parents to understand this scary part of the adult world. If the parents are fighting over the kid's future already, it gets really confusing for the kid.
I've seen studies that indicate that parents who engage in protracted custody disputes have most of the symptoms of personality disorders. It's one reason I quit taking family law cases several years ago- I'd rather take the afternoon off than spend it on something like that.
So here I go again forcing boundaries on parents who have none of their own. God, it gets tiring.
It's a given that the kid has to make his/her own decisions about the case. In Juvenile Court, though, they tend to rely on their parents to understand this scary part of the adult world. If the parents are fighting over the kid's future already, it gets really confusing for the kid.
I've seen studies that indicate that parents who engage in protracted custody disputes have most of the symptoms of personality disorders. It's one reason I quit taking family law cases several years ago- I'd rather take the afternoon off than spend it on something like that.
So here I go again forcing boundaries on parents who have none of their own. God, it gets tiring.
Monday, September 15, 2008
I've been doing a lot of child support contempt hearings recently- i.e. "pay your child support or you're going to jail!"
What I'm realizing is that the huge numbers you see these days for child support left unpaid these days by "deadbeat dads" are mostly illusionary. What they consist of is child support that wasn't calculated correctly in the first place.
This morning I was talking to a typical mope in this position. I'm going over the original order with him:
"This says you earned a gross of $5000 per month at the time, making your child support $1250 per month. That right?"
"Naw, I never earned $5000 a month in my life."
"Why the #@%$ did you sign this off saying you did, then?"
"I wanted the divorce over and I figured she would settle down once it was done with."
Four years later, she's asking for him to go to jail because he's not paying $1250 per month support out of a take-home of $1200.
Now, obviously he bears most of the blame for signing off on the $1250 per month support in the first place. My point, though, is that his ex was never actually entitled to that; his correct support amount should have been around $350- which he actually could pay. The $900 per month difference is an illusion that he never earned or should have owed.
That probably makes him stupid. It doesn't make him a deadbeat, and shouldn't be counted as part of the huge backlog of unpaid child support you hear so much about.
What I'm realizing is that the huge numbers you see these days for child support left unpaid these days by "deadbeat dads" are mostly illusionary. What they consist of is child support that wasn't calculated correctly in the first place.
This morning I was talking to a typical mope in this position. I'm going over the original order with him:
"This says you earned a gross of $5000 per month at the time, making your child support $1250 per month. That right?"
"Naw, I never earned $5000 a month in my life."
"Why the #@%$ did you sign this off saying you did, then?"
"I wanted the divorce over and I figured she would settle down once it was done with."
Four years later, she's asking for him to go to jail because he's not paying $1250 per month support out of a take-home of $1200.
Now, obviously he bears most of the blame for signing off on the $1250 per month support in the first place. My point, though, is that his ex was never actually entitled to that; his correct support amount should have been around $350- which he actually could pay. The $900 per month difference is an illusion that he never earned or should have owed.
That probably makes him stupid. It doesn't make him a deadbeat, and shouldn't be counted as part of the huge backlog of unpaid child support you hear so much about.
Saturday, September 13, 2008
Not just a river in Egypt
Ten days ago, a mother calls me absolutely hysterical that her (16 YO) daughter is being held in custody for the first week of school. Her Highness was arrested over the long weekend when the cops found her drunk in a car with her equally drunk boyfriend. I point out to her that this is the third similar incident in less than a year. She doesn't want to hear it: the on-duty lawyer was a "public pretender"- scores a lot of points with me- the probation officer didn't care about her daughter, the prosecutor was a jerk, the judge was rude, and anyway it was only one beer, Her Highness had a hard day at the fast food emporium, and why should we believe the PBT, and, and, and... and I need to get down to the courthouse and get her released before school starts tomorrow. I explain that it Ain't Gonna Happen- no doubt making me (on the 19th anniversary of my swearing in to the Bar) something less than a Real Lawyer.
I call around to see what's up, and discover that HH has DUI charges in two local courts that she didn't mention to anyone at Juvenile Court. In one, she was racing the same boyfriend on one of the main arterials- both drunk again- and lost control of her car. Luckily, she missed any other cars when she spun out and hit the curb on the other side of the street. When the same cop that busted her for that found her drunk in a car AGAIN, she became a guest of the State, bringing us back to the start of this story.
Yesterday I'm talking to HH, who is actually a pretty nice kid. I got her into Drug Court, and she's got her head straight and is ready to step up and deal with the problem (we'll see if she remembers that once she gets out). She mentions that her family has a history of alcoholism, and that Mom smelled of alcohol when she came to visit the other day.
AH HA. Suddenly this all makes sense!
I call around to see what's up, and discover that HH has DUI charges in two local courts that she didn't mention to anyone at Juvenile Court. In one, she was racing the same boyfriend on one of the main arterials- both drunk again- and lost control of her car. Luckily, she missed any other cars when she spun out and hit the curb on the other side of the street. When the same cop that busted her for that found her drunk in a car AGAIN, she became a guest of the State, bringing us back to the start of this story.
Yesterday I'm talking to HH, who is actually a pretty nice kid. I got her into Drug Court, and she's got her head straight and is ready to step up and deal with the problem (we'll see if she remembers that once she gets out). She mentions that her family has a history of alcoholism, and that Mom smelled of alcohol when she came to visit the other day.
AH HA. Suddenly this all makes sense!
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Goldilocks and crim pro
This morning one of the commissioners I regularly appear before decided to explain the criminal process to some 11 year old using the analogy of Goldilocks and the three bears. Naturally, at the break, I had to goof on her:
"These handcuffs are tooooo loose!"
"These handcuffs are tooooo tight!"
"These handcuffs are juuuust right!"
Turn around to find some parent staring at me in disbelief. Hey, do this for a while and see if you start to think this way...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)